Menu
Investing
Are Dell, HP zombie stocks?
Gun industry, gun stocks have boomed under Obama
Fertilizer standoff for Potash of Saskatchewan
PepsiCo has a new sweetener mix
Inside Wall Street: Chipotle may remain weak
What's wrong with McDonald's?
Secret Santa for stock pickers
Harley revs up in India
Gold ETF poised to test key support
Merck drops as heart drug falls short in study
Is Yum Brands having a problem in China?
Can United Continental fly higher?
How much will the market tank on tax bill failure?
Bond trap in the wake of a US credit downgrade
Boehner's defeat is no big deal
Recreational vehicles keep driving forward
Michael Kors dresses for success in 2013
Dear RIM: Wall Street doesn't date losers
3 industries set for a fiscal cliff dive
Futures drop on fiscal cliff fears
Why Altria is overvalued
Brazil: Next international frontier for Gap
Top picks 2013: CVS and Yahoo
To Michigan governor: If it ain't broke, don't fix it
Energy bills: Ofgem must take firmer action, MPs say
Stronger action is needed to ensure energy customers get a fair deal, a committee of MPs has told the regulator Ofgem.

The MPs have called on it to be less timid in dealing with "anti-competitive" behaviour by suppliers.

They also warned that recent plans by Ofgem and the government might still fail to help customers make meaningful price comparisons "at a glance".

Ofgem said it would analyse the details of the report before responding.

The report of the Energy and Climate Change Committee said: "We find it unsatisfactory that Ofgem should be so hesitant about launching preliminary investigations into potentially anti-competitive behaviour.

"We understand that Ofgem plans to reduce barriers to competition... but we believe that a more proactive approach should be adopted."

An Ofgem spokesman said: "We do share the committee's concern about transparency, which is why we publish a weekly report setting out wholesale and retail prices."

"We also share the committee's concerns about competition in the energy market, which is why we are progressing with the most far-reaching reforms since competition began, to make it simpler, clearer and fairer for consumers."

The MPs welcomed the recent initiatives by Ofgem and the government to force suppliers to offer customers a much smaller and simpler range of tariffs, but said stronger action might be needed quickly if the proposals did not work.

"Whether or not these measures will improve the situation for consumers remains to be seen, but it is crucial that if they do not, the government and Ofgem are prepared to take stronger action to ensure that consumers get a fair deal from energy providers," the MPs said.

"Ofgem should be prepared to amend the measures it has implemented if there is no evidence after 12 months that they are making it easier for consumers to switch."
'Confusion marketing'

The MPs' report highlighted well-known problems: that not enough people are willing to switch suppliers and that they are particularly put off by the vast and confusing array of tariffs on offer.

The MPs said the big six energy firms took advantage of customer inertia to overcharge people who never switch, while offering cheap "loss leader" deals to lure new customers.

That in turn made it harder for smaller suppliers to break into the market, stifling the competition that might help keep prices down.

"In a healthy market, suppliers would compete for a share of the market by continually striving to offer better deals, or by offering a unique or particularly high standard of service to differentiate themselves from competitors," the MPs said.

"Currently, the opposite appears to be true of the energy market, with suppliers adopting similar pricing and hedging strategies, adding to consumers' perception that suppliers are 'all the same'."

"If the largest suppliers have millions of customers who are unlikely to switch, there is little incentive for suppliers to offer these 'sticky' customers lower prices or a better service," the report added.
Unfair prices?

Consumers are in the middle of another round of price increases, with E.On recently becoming the last of the big six to raise prices this winter.

In October 2011, Ofgem began an attack on the "confusion marketing" tactics of the energy industry by proposing that each supplier should be compelled to offer basic "no-frills" tariffs so that customers could compare them easily.

Last month the regulator revised this plan, suggesting that each supplier should offer a maximum of only four tariffs each for gas and electricity.

But Ofgem was then trumped when the government announced its own variation on these plans: that all current customers should be moved to the cheapest of those tariffs, not merely have them highlighted to them, as Ofgem had been proposing.

The consumer organisation Which? renewed its own attack on energy suppliers, accusing them of still trying to bamboozle customers over their new tariffs.

Which? said the government's recent proposals needed to be made even stronger, by introducing a single unit price for energy, a quicker switching process, and with all tariffs becoming available for all types of payment.

"After the recent round of price hikes and announcements about the cost to consumers of investment in the energy system, it's no wonder people are left questioning whether the price they are paying is a fair one," said Richard Lloyd of Which?
Rising bills

One step the MPs recommended was that all firms should be forced to publish a figure for their costs per customer, so that any loss leading deals would be clear to competitors, though the MPs said these below-cost tariffs should not be banned.

The MPs also expressed their concern that most members of the public did not realise that energy bills were going to keep on rising substantially, and that most people would seriously have to consider ways of improving their home insulation or cutting their gas and electricity usage.

Paul Massara, who will next month take up the chief executive role at energy firm RWE Npower, said he looked forward to an "open conversation" with the committee.

"We share the concern about the growing pressure on all households, especially those in poverty, as fuel bills rise due to the cost of replacing the energy infrastructure, government and regulatory policies and world energy markets," he said.

"I therefore welcome the call for a transparent market and would also support an honest conversation about energy costs; we will ourselves promote a simple, transparent and honest engagement with customers and others."

Для печати
Mario Monti 'available to lead Italy'
Norwegian minister Espen Eide urges UK caution on quitting EU
Bank reform plans should be tougher, Banking Commission says
US fiscal cliff: Boehner still hopes for deal
Alcohol duty fraud: Action needed, say off-licences
LSE agrees LCH Clearnet deal at lower price
Retailers predict 'acceptable' Christmas trading figures
Retailers 'facing critical financial issues'
Wal-Mart pulls ad, Dick's halts assault rifle sales
Fix fiscal cliff or risk downgrade, says Fitch
What a new inflation measure would mean for your wallet
Citigroup shareholders push for break up
Buyers prepare bids for Hostess assets
O'Reilly AlphaTech closes third venture fund
Twilight poised to lift Hollywood to record year
Wal-Mart warns workers on Black Friday strike
The looming disaster the Fed's stress tests miss
4 ways Wall Street can ante up for fiscal health
Dividend investors prepare for fiscal cliff
Middle East violence pushes oil prices up
NYSE hires former homeland security chief
Bank of Japan punts on rates amid political turmoil
The 1% bets on the fiscal cliff
Exclusive: Sun Capital wants to buy Hostess
Green Mountain names new CEO
No merger bonuses for Xstrata execs
Eurozone risks rising as outlook darkens
Fiscal cliff: A modest proposal
Top picks 2013: ARM Holdings
Has Mario Monti done a good job?
The fresh approach to keeping deliveries like clockwork
Retirement: Doom and gloom or golden opportunity?
Clinton Cards has a new look, but can its reinvention work?
GB Paralympics funding increased
Rangers share issue raises £22m
BAE Systems wins £2.5bn Oman Hawk and Typhoon contract
Blackberry-maker Research in Motion sees big fall in profits
Bank of Japan boosts stimulus to help revive growth
UK retail sales flat in November
US home sales hit three-year high as GDP revised up
Energy bills: Ofgem must take firmer action, MPs say
Home rental costs record rare dip, says LSL
Insurance rules on gender will alter prices
Facebook tests charging $1 to send messages to strangers
Cathay Pacific averts cabin crew industrial action
ArcelorMittal cuts $4.3bn from value of Europe business
BMG buys up rights to thousands of hit songs
Statoil to create 700 jobs in North Sea development
News Corporation says publishing arm lost $2.1bn
UK borrowing higher than expected as GDP revised down
Nike shares jump 6.2% on strong home demand
Steve Jobs' high-tech yacht impounded over bill dispute